Is an Airbnb Near Broadway Worth It? Pros & Cons

Spencer Ludwig
Jan 2
3 min read

TL;DR — The Real Answer

Staying near Broadway is usually better than staying directly on it for group trips
Being too close to Broadway often means more noise, crowds, smaller spaces, and less sleep
A short ride away gives groups more space, privacy, flexibility, and calmer mornings—without losing easy access to nightlife
Homes like The Herman Haven hit the sweet spot: quick Broadway access without the chaos, plus room to get ready, pregame, and actually relax

If you’re planning a Nashville bachelorette or group trip, you’ve probably asked this question (or argued about it in a group chat):

“Should we stay right by Broadway?”

The honest answer: it depends—but for most groups, being slightly outside the strip leads to a better weekend overall.

Here’s a clear breakdown of the pros and cons of staying near Broadway, so you can decide what actually fits your group.

✅ The Pros of Staying Near Broadway

1️⃣ Fast, Easy Nights Out

Being close to Broadway means:

Short Uber rides
Easy late-night returns
Less planning stress

For bachelorettes especially, this convenience matters after long nights dancing.

2️⃣ Maximum Flexibility

When nightlife is nearby, you can:

Head out earlier
Pop back to change outfits
Call it a night without coordinating a long ride

This freedom is a huge plus for groups with mixed energy levels.

3️⃣ First-Timer Friendly

If it’s your group’s first Nashville trip, staying near Broadway keeps the city easy to navigate and helps everyone feel oriented quickly.

❌ The Cons of Staying On Broadway

1️⃣ Noise (All. Night. Long.)

Broadway doesn’t really sleep. Sirens, party buses, live music, and crowds can make:

Falling asleep harder
Sleeping in nearly impossible

For multi-day trips, that adds up fast.

2️⃣ Smaller Spaces for Groups

Properties directly downtown tend to be:

Condos or hotel-style units
Tighter layouts
Limited common areas

Not ideal if your group wants to get ready together, pregame, or hang out at home.

3️⃣ Fewer Private Amenities

Hot tubs, patios, fire pits, and fenced yards are rare right on Broadway—but these are often the spaces groups end up loving most.

🎯 The Sweet Spot: Close, But Not On It

This is where experienced Nashville planners land.

Staying just outside the Broadway core gives you:

Quick, affordable rides
Quieter nights
More space to spread out
Better value for groups

Homes in nearby neighborhoods are designed for real living—not just sleeping between bar hops.

That’s why so many groups choose places like The Herman Haven, which sits about 1.9 miles from Broadway—close enough for spontaneity, far enough for comfort.

When Staying ON Broadway Makes Sense

There are times when staying directly downtown works:

Very small groups (2–4 people)
One-night stays
Groups that won’t spend time at the house

If your group plans to be out all day and night and doesn’t care about shared space, a downtown condo or hotel may be fine.

When Staying NEAR Broadway Is the Better Choice

Most bachelorette and group trips fall into this category:

You want to get ready together
Pregame at home
Have outdoor space
Sleep well between nights out

In those cases, being a short ride away delivers a smoother, more enjoyable weekend.

Final Takeaway

Broadway is where the party happens—but it doesn’t have to be where you sleep.

For groups who want fun and comfort, staying near Broadway strikes the perfect balance: easy access, calmer mornings, and space to actually enjoy being together.

👉 If you’re planning daytime adventures alongside nightlife, our /things-to-do-nashville guide pairs well with this location strategy.

FAQs — Staying Near Broadway

How far is “near Broadway”?Usually within 2–3 miles is ideal for quick rides without downtown noise.

Are Ubers easy late at night?Yes—rides are plentiful, though prices surge after big events.

Will we miss out by not staying on Broadway?Not at all. You’ll still spend plenty of time there—just sleep better elsewhere.